EdibleCastle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Cliff of Death]

...

hehe, thats some random stuff u got going on there! u must have an odd brain. keep up the good work, you're getting better!

[Geometry and You]

...

really boring. graphics were ok. sound sucked as did the whole concept of this. the graphic style didnt stay constant either

gene-goldstein responds:

The sound is SUPPOSED TO SUCK. And the Graphic stayed constant, you're just blind.

[The Breakfast Club]

...

hehe lovin it. great choice of music to accompany the animation. my favourite piece of animation was the rolling croissant... oooo i had 2 the other day and there were delicious.

[Eddsworld Christmas '04]

...

oh god that was terrible. well i think it was.. i couldnt watch all the way thru. bad sound, bad humor, bad animation, bad graphics, and i'll take a guess at .. bad storyline. i dont understand how u have (at present) a 3.61 score with this. oh well... congrats.

eddsworld responds:

because you never watched the whole thing

[Billy Beck in the Robbery]

...

hmmmmm... i hope that wasnt a solid month of animating. u have potential. but the animation skills were definitely lacking. the graphics were pretty poor too..... u got all your angles n perspectives wrong

[GEOWeasel Pilot Ep Part 1]

...

u got alot of potential. the graphics are a bit poor. your style doesnt stay the same throughout the movie. some of the jokes were alright! i like a good comedy pause or 2 (: .. the sound was probably the worst thing about this cartoon. really low quality. the voice acting wasnt bad tho. just get a better mic or recording programme or soundcard or something (: anyway. i think it was a good effort. alot of work put into it i think.

[A Very Shabot Christmas]

...

not bad. best thing about this production was the sound quality. gj on that, so many ppl overlook how important sound is to their movies.

shabot6000 responds:

Thank you, I try not to compress the audio to the point of distortion. The audio in this Flash movie was rendered at 128kbps stereo mp3. Glad you enjoyed it!

Ben

[Animation Tutorial 4 FX]

better than the last

the fire and water examples looked the best imo. the smoke looked a bit gnarly, but the others were ok/good. still just watch out for basic spelling errors and typos, that sorta thing. oh u shouldnt even bother putting the "now just a word here" page in. oh and the last page button cuts the music off.

JackSmack responds:

Thanks for saying the tutorials are getting better. And yes the smoke looks a bit gnarly but it is great for small file sizes. Sorry about the button killing the music. was something I missed I guess. did it so when you hit the button it didn't play another music track on top of the one already playing. And I appologize for any spelllingg errors. I'm not perfect... but hey I want to help people.

[MK BATTLES #1]

why?

i dont get it. what was the point in making that? why not just play the game... the animation is better and is 100% more interactive. that was a poor attempt at.... um... a poor attempt at..... er... i dunno what u were attempting, but it was poor for sure.