EdibleCastle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[SKATER V2 Episode: 04]

nice work

nice work. love the style of animation and facial expressions. but I thought the layout work in some shots needed a bit of re-thinking and perhaps you broke the art style a bit much for my liking. but overall gj

MarcyVF responds:

I'll try re-thinking the shorts, I get your point. Thanks for the review :)

[The Telescopal Terror]

perfection

this should be on tv!

or at least - straight to DVD.

Wiiporter responds:

ahahaha, coming from you, that's amazing.

Maybe if I shamelessly advertise Cartoon Network, they'll give me a job :D

[Dining with the Devil]

sweet

great job fella. really enjoyed it. it oozed with class and style, oozed.

[Metal Gear Timelapse]

you can draw well

nice drawing, you have talent.

Maybe I've seen too many speed painting movies online to full appreciate this or maybe I'm giving it a 2 because it's a drawing.

I still think it's a good piece of artwork but compared to something I think deserving of a 10 like perhaps Waterlollies where there's great artwork on everyframe... it's a 2 in my book.

anyway, good job. I'm sure any more of these you submit will be just as well received. hats off

[William the Br00t]

sweet

I like to think I'll turn out like that when I'm older. I've got the name already, just need the funky moves.

Evil-Chef responds:

haha i love your stuff bro

[Another Day Eight]

lacking...

First off I've gotta give respect for the amount of hours you must have spent on this. But I have pretty major gripes concerning the lack of apparent thought put in.

I'm all for slow, peaceful flash movies as long as they counteract the lack of action with some thing else to tick the entertainment box. I couldn't really find it, maybe I wasn't looking hard enough, maybe it wasn't there, maybe I'm missing the point.

The animation was really good, I like the shaky style but some of the artwork didn't quite hit the spot for me. I know you went for a mellow colour palette to suit the whole tone of the movie but in my opinion it just came across as dull. A dullness that was highlighted further with the song, which i felt was just a little bit too dreary and I didn't care much for the singing.

Well anyway, just my honest opinions, catch you later.

The-Super-Flash-Bros responds:

Wow, a review from EdibleCastle! Thanks.

I guess its not for everyone. A lot of people do just watch it and say "what was the point of that?". I guess I want it to be kind of empty, because when I try and shoehorn in a storyline it feels forced. This world and these characters just aren't suited to drama of any sort. I know what you mean about "something else to tick the entertainment box".

Anyway I'm glad you liked the animation. I'm a big fan of Cuboy, so it means a lot coming from you.

-Dim

[Mastermind 3]

gosh!

this flash movie gave me sweaty parts.

[Mastermind 2]

gee willikers

that was class. love the outside shots, the rapid dialogue and the jokes. gave me sweaty balls. thanks.

[William & The Mice]

flawless

The only part of this whole production I didnt enjoy was having to send Brady a topless photo of myself. 'Just for reference' he said...

...I'm not so sure

[Going Grim]

nice one

well done Stephen! This is the best thing I've seen from you to date!

Don't read into my rating too much... i'm a pretty hard to impress.

Good luck in the comp!

Evilcactus responds:

Thanks for the appropriate rating, Will. Yes it is the best thing you have seen because i have no other animations up.