EdibleCastle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Weebl & Bob Tribute]

...

maaaaan i hate 'tributes'. i dont understand why anyone would want to remake something they've seen and liked. but putting that feeling aside..

decently animated.
sound was ok, but voices were shit.

everything was trying to be as accurate as possible right?
if thats the case then the text was too big ( i think, havent watched weebl n bob in awhile) and badly positioned.
and the tempo and timing was way off. that was probably the worst part of this - the timing of when they speak and respond to each other.

[TLOZ: The Lock of Time]

...

locks and zelda... what a bad combination. for me at least.
um that red text on the dulled subtitled area is hard on the eyes.
jokes were pretty lame.
graphics not too bad.
sound like u said... u know it sux.
sorry, this just didnt interest me. i hate clock and locks. i'm trying to be fair. but i judge alot on originality and that was no where to be seen in this movie.
parodies r fine if they're done well.

this wasnt.

[Foamy Fan Mail 5 (A.T.A.)]

...

i havent seen the other fan mail episodes..but this .... wait... i think i might have seen a few.... hmm.... they couldnt have left a lasting impression on me. i've seen other foamy episodes. ah right yeah. with the chick. blah blah what's her face. anyway cutting to the chase. i didnt enjoy this. its getting pretty old. well really old. well in my opinion anyway. alot of people are still enjoying your work.... and so it pains me a bit to say this... i guess the only sensible thing to do is continue making foamy movies. sigh.

[Peoplemation: Spin]

...

haha what a great story. good ending too.
you guys musta looked like such idiots to people watching u film that from their houses. haha great stuff

Dustball responds:

Yes, plus there's that whole "getting run over by a car" problem!

[AGE]

...

alot of potential. this could have been better.
just wasnt consistant enough.
the choice of words was poor.
graphics were great... did u see the movie 'catch me if u can'? at times very similar to the intro of that film.
the music cut out for me about 3/4 of the way thru then came back in. dunno if that was meant or not.

so yeah... pretty good. great style... just not quite polished enough.

[Oddgods-3]

...

this shoulda got at least 3rd place for the day. so much more interesting than stuff normally submitted by others. i didnt have a clue what was going on. havent watched any other episodes. but i'm sure that doesnt matter much. gj, keep making different movies.

[Jail-Break]

...

relatively well animated. high marks for that. u're lucky good animation hasnt got anything to do with originallity here. you have bags of skills. why dont u think up a great new type of story and try to make something new and fresh.

[project_rowdy]

...

good drawings but not sure if the different kinds of graphics worked well with each other. also dont think that music was appropriate. very slow panning animation - very fast tempo music. hmmmm
good luck with it.

[The next Motoko 1]

...

watch for typos, 'chenking'?
sound wasnt great...
graphics tried to be good but didnt quite make it.
good luck with your future productions tho

[AikiDOG on Columbia?!]

...

sound was good. as was the intro. after that it was just plain lazy with no effort involved