00:00
00:00
EdibleCastle

125 Movie Reviews

35 w/ Responses

2 reviews are hidden due to your filters.

...

as always, a very nicely drawn and animated movie.

The humor is very old fashioned and something that could perhaps be worked on.. but then again, it suits the general style of the movie.

one thing that i think spoiled it was the below average attempt of a Scottish accent. it kinda sounded russian at times.

good job.

...

you're progressing with each and every new animation gobi. the story generally flowed pretty well I'd say. the music was well acquired and style was excellent. nice touches with use of 3D. some good fbf stuff in there too. only problems i had with this was firstly the text used... how you stretch it an' stuff to fit... looks bad from a designers point of view. um.. the woman looked slightly more cartoony than the rest of the movie. and the background at the end behind the man... i didnt understand it. there were trees and things on one side.... then a severe cut to blackness (if i'm remembering correctly). but yeah. excellent work! this should get daily first.. and if it doesnt.... i'll eat my ...um....my.... actually.... i wont. but yeah. well done!

...

i love the style of this. and pretty good humour too. I havent caught any of the other episodes of this series but i might watch some later. but yeah anyway... this deserved much more than daily 5th. its gold! shoulda had daily 1st for sure.

Miggs responds:

Thanks for the support, man! One day we'll get Daily Feature.

...

heh. i enjoyed this little ditty. that's some wholesome entertainment right there. take it easy.

...

i very much enjoyed the camera movements and effects used. very well done there.

...

the last one was made much better than the first 2. the first two were well below the standard of the 3rd.

Xionico responds:

thanks XD, well the other ones were somewhat old projects that i never released, so i think its normal that the other one which is recent is better than the other ones.
great work on calderbank 2 =O!

...

weekly first? wow. good job.

but i dont understand why this is so popular. it must be because u put alot of effort into this... and it was a good length!

the graphics in parts were good.. and let themselves down continually throughout. as did the animation... the style of both animation and graphics would change too.

very badly produced. i saw a border or something at one point at the side of the screen... subtitled text would come out of its border at points. some girls hair went UNDER her eyebrow and eye. i could go on and on. nothing fitted. just generally badly produced.

the voice acting and quality of sound was pretty good tho. gj there.

one other thing... u have no design skills. u need to get better at that.. your cartoons would improve if u do this.

but hell. u have a 4.2+ score here. u probably wont listen to much of this criticism. but seriously.... you should. i'm just trying to help.

Toonimated responds:

hehe of course i listen to all critism, specially from the dude of Whitmooooooooooore the tooooaaaaaaaddd Piiiiraaate! Lmao i love those series. u should keep doing them.

"yes, yes, we know" lmao

Ehhh, well thanks for ur review, the quality changes as hell because we are 2 artists in this one. so that might be the reason. about the borders, thats wierd...havent seen them...would be cool if u point them out...

Peace!!!
WHIIIIIITMOOOOOOOOOOOOREEE THE TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAD PIIIIRATEE

...

no. that was terrible. why does it have such a high score? the graphics were bad. the animation was worse. eg. why did the characters facial features move so independantly from the rest of their face? that was bog awful.

Quimera responds:

hey its again you!!!!!

WHITMOOOOOOREEE THE TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAAD PIRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAATE!

hey un stop being an ass? lol. its like...ur movie graphics arent mind blowing....so....stop being like that.

Anyway

WHIIIIIIITMOOOOOOOOOOOREEEEEEEEEEE THEEEEEEEEE TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAD PIIIIIIIIIIRAAAAATE

...

character graphics were good, backgrounds were kinda shoddy but thats not what this animation was about... the feeling it conveyed is what really mattered.

this worked well... wasnt perfect by any means... but it worked well.

...

I see "ma$sacre 2" with have a new theme. Sorry...um... what was ma$sacre's theme? I think it must have slipped me by.

Stick men fighting..... how interesting. but some credit must be given to SV3 who had at least had solid figures in there and Royale-Wit-Cheese who showed off some nice light effects.

All in all pretty damn boring. I've just rolled outta bed and this was the last thing I woulda chosen to try'n waken me up a bit.

Will Arbuckle @EdibleCastle

Male

Creative Designer

Edinburgh, UK

Joined on 3/29/03

Level:
11
Exp Points:
1,120 / 1,350
Exp Rank:
58,512
Vote Power:
5.27 votes
Rank:
Town Watch
Global Rank:
53,042
Blams:
110
Saves:
43
B/P Bonus:
2%
Whistle:
Normal
Trophies:
35
Medals:
73
Gear:
2