EdibleCastle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Two Men & a Brick]

...

hey there fremont, got some good stuff in there! a real story too! i like stories. everything was ranging from 'not bad' to 'good' except for the sound... it was pretty low quality. nice one tho!

[Spaced Out! (Pilot)]

...

good idea for a series..... kinda like red dwarf or something? with the cat n all.. and the robot.... but robots are pretty common in sci-fi.... so i'll let that one go.

graphics were pretty good as was the animation.... humor let it down a bit... just needs worked upon. gj

grim-studios responds:

Thanks. I know the humor needs work, but hopefully that will change with the next episode.

[Milk a Cow(Revised)]

...

could see you've put a bit of effort into this. but really.. the final outcome is poor. bad animation and worse graphics. i quite like the song you chose...but thats about it.

[Boot to the Head!]

...

not bad.

timing of the animation with the music was great. some funny little scenarios in there. and quite well thought out in general. the animation was done well too.

the graphics weren't the best....look a bit childish and without style. but they worked to some extent. i didnt find the song itself that funny... but obviously its got great lyrics to use in a flash movie. gj

[Floyd The Snail]

...

good grief.. that indeed was EPIC! i liked the music choice and whole story... such a tragic ending.... just the sorta ending i love.

some of the graphics are a bit off... but u get away with it bcoz of the amount of detail u've put in. some real nice touches throughout the movie like the butterfly at the start.

i liked the blur effects to give depth in the movie... but perhaps at times the effect was overused and interfered with the graphics.. (eg, floyds shell is blurred as its in the background.... then the tree falls behind him... and its not blurred) just a small point.. but something to tidy up on.

some great water splash animation really gave the animation a bit of class.. well done.

enjoyed immensely!

Gobi responds:

hah! thanks will, i never notice the Shell-blur thing, although in another scene, you'll note that the tree is in fact blurred . :P. just one of things that make you go hmmm.

[If...]

...

i know it was meant to be ultra subtle etc.... but a bit more animation wouldnt have been a bad thing......

it had its own style.... but really the graphics r nothing to boast about, could have been tidied up a bit.

loved the music used.. that was perfect..

oh and the font... twas nice.

but yeah.. all n all.. i enjoyed this... very refreshing compared to the usual submissions. goodjob!

[A Men's Room Monologue]

...

pretty funny.... shame about the graphics and animation.

the thing i related to most was the push button taps where the water turns off as soon as your hand leaves the button.

[Black Jellybean 3]

...

good stuff... liked the voice acting and eye/eyebrow expressions... not too keen on the lipsyncing. but all in all i liked this.

mmmm just one other thing... that 50X50 pixel thumbnail of it doesnt do the cartoon any favours.

[-Where it Ends-]

...

heyhey. i liked that. especially the bit where the dude is building the bomb. then he does that finger movement and presses in the last bit. that was sweet. did it go out of focus on close ups? or was it just the compression?

so yeah. musta taken a wee while making that. i give respect. only other thing missing was some voices perhaps (even tho the story was obvious enough to do without)

noticed I'm in your favourites list with calderbank. cheers for that.

Freemont responds:

Hell yes!! I love Calderbank!!

[Roy's Foxy Hat]

amazing!

omfg kano that was brilliant. another Roy classic! and check out the review a few previous to this one.. some guy said my theme song sounded professional. LOL i rock. but seriously... keep up the good work man!