EdibleCastle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Roy's Snowshoes]

...

one of the best things i have ever seen. the special effects were awesome! and i loved the way the teapot exploded when the yellow camera laughed at the dennis

[Sweet Mother of Vartan]

...

brilliant! top notch animation.... dont see many like these around. glad i caught this! it really shoulda been daily no.1 (altho i havent watched #1,2 and 3, just about to. but i'm sure they're not as good as this) and def worthy of a weekly no.1. looking forward to more work coming from u. brilliant.

[Broken Saints Ch 6 Act 2]

...

i found this incredibly boring. i mean... wow ... theres potential...... if u just mixed in some animation perhaps? i mean.... it SO slow moving.... not enough image changes in there to keep it interesting.....

i found the text too heavy going... but the whole production was about the text... and what it was saying.... um... what WAS it saying?

you have art skills... not bad at illustrating.... but for this type of thing perhaps u need even BETTER drawing skills.

one great thing about the animation was some of the effects used.... nicely done.

in general the animation was produced very well... but again... it was just so damn SLOW... ALLL..........THE...........TIME......... i'm pretty proud of myself that i sat thru it all.

top marks for your style.... consistent.... interesting.... and not afraid to subtley break from it from time to time.

maybe i'm just not in to this sorta thing?

[-Let it B-]

...

was this anything new or different? i'm not a fan of this clock stuff... i've seen a few movies... they all seem quite similar. everything has a shelf life i guess. has this stuff reached its? i mean what more can be done with this genre of flash? can u guys bring anything interesting to NGs? the movie just felt stale.

[The Cliff of Death]

...

hehe, thats some random stuff u got going on there! u must have an odd brain. keep up the good work, you're getting better!

[Geometry and You]

...

really boring. graphics were ok. sound sucked as did the whole concept of this. the graphic style didnt stay constant either

gene-goldstein responds:

The sound is SUPPOSED TO SUCK. And the Graphic stayed constant, you're just blind.

[The Breakfast Club]

...

hehe lovin it. great choice of music to accompany the animation. my favourite piece of animation was the rolling croissant... oooo i had 2 the other day and there were delicious.

[Eddsworld Christmas '04]

...

oh god that was terrible. well i think it was.. i couldnt watch all the way thru. bad sound, bad humor, bad animation, bad graphics, and i'll take a guess at .. bad storyline. i dont understand how u have (at present) a 3.61 score with this. oh well... congrats.

eddsworld responds:

because you never watched the whole thing

[Billy Beck in the Robbery]

...

hmmmmm... i hope that wasnt a solid month of animating. u have potential. but the animation skills were definitely lacking. the graphics were pretty poor too..... u got all your angles n perspectives wrong

[GEOWeasel Pilot Ep Part 1]

...

u got alot of potential. the graphics are a bit poor. your style doesnt stay the same throughout the movie. some of the jokes were alright! i like a good comedy pause or 2 (: .. the sound was probably the worst thing about this cartoon. really low quality. the voice acting wasnt bad tho. just get a better mic or recording programme or soundcard or something (: anyway. i think it was a good effort. alot of work put into it i think.