EdibleCastle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Handmade Clothes]

...

those flashback bits.... oh dear.. if you're gonna do them.. u gotta really make sure it's a good gag. otherwise.... u get people like me saying "oh dear" and cringing.

it really does deserve a score of about 2 i'd say - "nothing to new or interesting" sums it up perfectly.

[Monster In The Mansion]

...

how lovely. that was such a pleasant movie. sigh, thank you.

[The BINGE-er-bread Man]

...

hehe, this shoulda got first place. oh god tho.... the end.... disgusting.

[DragonBall Ecks]

...

some good animation in there. anime doesnt do it for me tho. you got bags of potential! increase your fps and get some more inbetweening going. gj. oh and why not try thinking up an original story etc.

[Talon VS Salocin - Part 1]

...

for awhile there i was wondering why this had such a high score. but there was some great animation at the end. when i read the title... i thought it was just gonna be a straight out fighting movie.... but u've got some sorta story in there i think, which is good. i liked your drawings.. chars and BGs. some of it was far too cliché anime with the still pictures and zoomings. but all in all... this has alot of promise. gj

[x2200 and B.O.B.]

...

nice comic timing. has potential. sound sucked... u need a better way of getting a robot voice.... sometimes i couldnt make out what was being said. oh and the spanish flea music at the credits.... very overused. but yeah.... i'd have liked this more if you'd maybe had a few camera cuts and better sound. cool. nice one. cya.

Ironfistx responds:

Thanks alot for the feedback, I'll take that into consideration for the next one. I've gotta work on backing off those cliche's but I just loved the segway between the end of the movie and the spanish flea music. :)

[The Wet Side of Damp]

...

i wont pretend that i understood that, but i appreciate the amount of time you must have spent animating this. you must be proud. its a good 'un! just not my sorta thing. the music irritated me to be honest... the beat.... the clicky beat. just got in my ears somewhat.. u know? but anyway man. gj.

[The Cheas- Part 1]

...

overall i didnt like this much. humor wasnt great, neither was the animation or continuity of a few elements (eg the subtitles - could they be switched off? i didnt check the menu things at the top). the sound was alright but bad voice acting didnt help the poor material here.
the lip sync was good! oh and the peanuts girl whats her name? lucy? anyway yeah.... and one other thing i liked.. the sonic music at the end... that was sonic right? haha... anyway.... pretty lame in general... but with 1 or 2 nice touched thrown in. well done with those.

[legacy of kain animated]

...

totally unoriginal but great animation. thought it need sound fx tho.

[How Newgrounds Functions]

...

i dont believe there was any need to make this movie. too much stateing the bleedin obvious.